Choosing the right cigar ashtray is an important but often overlooked decision for new cigar smokers. A proper ashtray isn’t just about catching ash – it can affect your cigar experience and even reflect your personal style. We’ve all heard stories of improvised ashtrays (like a cut-in-half water bottle or even a hollowed-out tennis ball) used in desperation. Instead of resorting to those dreadful makeshift solutions, let’s learn about the two main types of cigar ashtrays: portable ashtrays and tabletop ashtrays, and how to choose the one that fits your needs (or why you might want both).
Portable cigar ashtrays are designed for cigar lovers on the go. They are typically compact, lightweight, and made to travel. If you enjoy cigars outdoors, at a friend’s house, or on the road, a portable ashtray can be a lifesaver. Many portable models have features to make mobile use easy – for example, some are shaped like cups that fit into a car’s cup holder and include a lid or cap to contain ashes and odors. A good portable ashtray lets you ash your cigar responsibly anywhere, without leaving a mess or requiring a nearby trash can.
These travel-friendly ashtrays come in various styles. Some are simple metal or heat-resistant plastic cups with a slot to rest your cigar, while others are foldable contraptions or pocket-sized trays. Often, portability means sacrificing size: most portable ashtrays hold only one cigar at a time and have limited capacity for ash. This makes them perfect for a single smoker or a short cigar break, but less ideal for long sessions or groups. For instance, the “personal” version of the popular Stinky ashtray line is a downsized model with a single cigar rest, perfect for a solo smoker and easier to store or pack away. In exchange for their small size, portable ashtrays offer convenience and discretion. Many include lids or covers that seal up, so you can snuff out your cigar and close the ashtray to lock in ash and smells until you can dispose of them properly. This is a huge plus if you’re smoking in a borrowed car or a public space where you want to leave no trace.
Portable ashtrays designed for travel – An example of portable cigar ashtrays is one meant to fit in your vehicle’s cup holder. These kinds of ashtrays are often made of metal and have caps or clips to hold your cigar securely while driving. They prevent ash from spilling and odors from escaping, keeping your surroundings clean and your cigar safe even in motion. Such ashtrays are practical and easy to use, making them a worthy addition to any cigar lover’s kit. Beyond the car, other portable designs include ashtray cans and pocket ashtrays. For example, Xikar’s popular portable ash can is essentially a miniature metal can with a cigar rest, perfect for use on a patio or campsite and small enough to toss in a travel bag. Some portable ashtrays even come as part of multi-tool kits – they might incorporate a removable ash dish along with accessories like a cutter and punch. This kind of all-in-one portability is great for new smokers because it packs everything you need in one package. (In fact, certain accessory bundles like the Drew Estate Cigar Accessories Kit include a travel-friendly ashtray alongside other essentials, so beginners can gear up with one purchase.)
Pros of Portable Ashtrays: The obvious advantage is mobility. A portable ashtray lets you enjoy a cigar wherever you are, without worrying about making a mess. It encourages good etiquette – you won’t be that person tapping ash on your friend’s nice patio or littering the park bench with cigar butts. Portables are also usually durable (often made of metal or heat-resistant plastic) since they’re meant to be carried around. Many have thoughtful features like snug-fitting lids, clips, or even wind-resistant designs to keep ashes from flying in breezes. They’re easy to clean too – just dump the ashes and give it a quick wipe. And because they’re small, you can store them in your car or drawer when not in use.
Cons of Portable Ashtrays: The trade-off for portability is limited capacity and stability. A tiny ashtray will fill up quickly if you’re smoking a large cigar or multiple cigars, meaning you may have to empty it mid-session. They are also generally lightweight, which means they can tip over more easily (unless secured in a cup holder or designed with a low center of gravity). If you often smoke in one place or with a group, a one-cigar ashtray can be inconvenient – each person might need their own, or you’ll be constantly dealing with ash buildup. In terms of aesthetics, portable ashtrays tend to be utilitarian. They get the job done but usually aren’t as visually impressive as a nice tabletop piece. Don’t expect a portable ashtray to serve as a room’s centerpiece; it’s more of a tool than décor. Finally, while some portables have clever features, they generally can’t match the presence and luxury feel that a big crystal or ceramic ashtray brings to the experience.
Despite the downsides, a portable ashtray is highly recommended for every cigar smoker’s arsenal. It’s better to have one and not need it all the time than to need one and not have it. Even if you do most of your smoking at home, you’ll appreciate having a travel ashtray the next time you go golfing, tailgating, or simply out on the porch on a windy day. Experienced aficionados often keep a portable ashtray handy in their car or cigar case – it’s a simple accessory that solves a lot of problems and shows courtesy to those around you.
Now let’s look at tabletop cigar ashtrays, the classic kind you might place on your coffee table, desk, or home bar. These are the larger, often heavier ashtrays designed to stay in one spot (at least for the duration of a cigar session). Tabletop ashtrays come in a huge variety of materials and designs, from simple glass dishes to ornate handmade pieces. What they have in common is that they prioritize stability, capacity, and style over portability. A good tabletop ashtray will safely hold your cigar and plenty of ash so you can sit back and enjoy, and it can also serve as a statement piece in your smoking area.
One key feature of tabletop ashtrays is the number of cigar rests (also called stirrups). Unlike a portable ashtray which usually accommodates just one cigar, a typical tabletop ashtray often has multiple grooves or rests to hold cigars – useful if you are smoking with friends or want to set down more than one cigar at a time. For example, La Flor Dominicana’s Andalusian Bull ashtray (inspired by their famous cigar) is a hefty oval ceramic ashtray with four gold-hued rests, allowing it to securely hold four cigars at once. Larger ashtrays like this are perfect for poker nights or herfs (group smoking sessions), where everyone can share one central ashtray. They also have the volume to collect ashes from several cigars without needing to be emptied frequently.
Another hallmark of tabletop ashtrays is their aesthetic appeal. Many are designed to be showpieces that reflect the owner’s taste or celebrate cigar culture. High-end brands produce beautiful ashtrays crafted from premium materials: think of glossy porcelain, crystal glass, marble, or fine woods. These pieces can be quite elegant – Davidoff’s luxury porcelain ashtrays, for instance, “bespeak richness and elegance” and are marketed as exquisite statement pieces for the home or office. In other words, a fine tabletop ashtray can double as decor. You might choose one with your favorite cigar brand’s logo or a design that matches your style, whether that’s a sleek modern metal ashtray or a vintage-looking ceramic dish. Cigar enthusiasts sometimes even collect unique ashtrays as conversation starters. (One creative example is a custom “cigar ash box” – essentially a wooden cigar box converted into an ashtray with a slate bottom to prevent burn marks. This kind of repurposed-item ashtray adds a rustic, personal touch to a room while still doing the job.)
Tabletop elegance: Shown above is a premium porcelain cigar ashtray by Davidoff in use. Tabletop ashtrays like this are built for both form and function – they provide a stable, heat-resistant place to rest your cigar, and they look great doing it. Many such ashtrays are made by prestigious manufacturers (often in famed porcelain centers like Limoges, France) and feature cigar-friendly design elements. For instance, the ashtray above has wide grooves to fit a cigar without pinching, and a deep bowl to collect ash so it won’t overflow during a long smoke. A quality tabletop ashtray will typically be heavy enough not to tip over if bumped and deep enough to protect against wind scattering your ash. In fact, ashtrays designed for outdoor patio use often have wind-proof deep bowls, and heavy crystal or ceramic models can sit sturdily even when there’s a breeze. The visual appeal is a big plus as well – a classy ashtray can complete the look of your cigar lounge or man cave. Whether it’s a sleek black marble ashtray or a colorful glazed ceramic with artful logos, it’s an accessory you can be proud to display.
Pros of Tabletop Ashtrays: The main advantages here are capacity, stability, and aesthetics. A larger ashtray can handle the ash from big cigars or multiple cigars easily, which means less frequent emptying and a cleaner environment during long smoking sessions. Multiple cigar rests allow each smoker to comfortably set down their cigar without crowding. Because they’re heavier, tabletop ashtrays are hard to accidentally knock over – a nice safety feature especially indoors (nobody wants hot ash or a lit cigar tumbling onto the carpet or coffee table). They are also usually made of sturdy, heat-resistant materials like ceramic, metal, glass, or stone, which won’t melt or scorch. A well-made ashtray can last decades with minimal wear. Another pro is how good they can look: a stylish ashtray adds character to your space and can even be a conversation piece. Cigar brands often release special-edition ashtrays that become collectibles (for example, the Andalusian Bull ashtray we mentioned, or limited series from Arturo Fuente, Padron, etc.). Using a branded or artistic ashtray subtly shows your appreciation for the cigar lifestyle. If you take care of it, a fine ashtray can also be a point of pride – something you enjoy as much as your cigar cutter or lighter in terms of craftsmanship.
Cons of Tabletop Ashtrays: The obvious downside is that they are not portable. A large crystal ashtray is meant to live on your table; you won’t be sticking it in your pocket or taking it on a hike. If you only have a big ashtray at home, you’ll still be stuck without a proper ash container when you leave the house or step outside a lounge. Additionally, some tabletop ashtrays, especially those made of breakable materials like glass or ceramic, require a bit of care. Drop a ceramic ashtray on a hard patio and it could crack or chip. Leaving a fancy ashtray outdoors in bad weather can also damage it – for example, one cigar aficionado shared that a beautiful ceramic ashtray of his “took quite a beating” after being unintentionally left out in the rain. So, there’s a little maintenance involved: you might need to hand-wash it (since many have finishes or logos you want to preserve) and remember to bring it inside if it’s not weatherproof. Another consideration is space – big ashtrays take up room. If your smoking area is small or you only smoke occasionally, a hefty four-cigar ashtray might be overkill. And finally, while not a real “con,” the nicer ashtrays can be expensive, reflecting their luxury materials and design. (We won’t go into cost here, but suffice it to say a hand-painted porcelain ashtray from a top brand will cost more than a basic glass dish. For many enthusiasts, the quality and look are worth it.)
That said, if you primarily smoke at home or have a regular spot in your office or den, investing in a good tabletop ashtray is highly worthwhile. It elevates the experience of smoking a cigar – you can rest your cigar securely, admire the wisps of smoke curling over a beautiful ashtray, and not worry about ashes fluttering away. For those who host cigar nights, a large ashtray is a must for practical reasons. And even for the casual lone smoker, there’s something satisfying about a substantial ashtray that complements the ritual of enjoying a cigar. It’s all part of the ambiance.
When deciding between a portable vs. tabletop cigar ashtray, consider your smoking habits and where you’ll be lighting up most often. As one guide wisely put it, “the most important thing to consider when choosing a cigar ashtray is where are you going to be using it most often?”. Your lifestyle will largely determine which type of ashtray makes sense:
If you’re frequently on the move or enjoy smoking outdoors in different places, a portable ashtray is probably essential. Do you often find yourself smoking in the car, on the golf course, at the beach, or in a friend’s backyard? A travel ashtray will serve you well. It ensures you always have a safe place to ash and dispose of your cigar, which is both polite and convenient. New smokers who haven’t set up a home smoking space yet might start with a portable ashtray so they can smoke wherever the opportunity arises. For example, if you live in an apartment and can only smoke outside or on a balcony, a portable (especially one with a cover to prevent wind from scattering ash) is a smart choice. It’s a small investment for a big increase in enjoyment and cleanliness. Plus, many portable ashtrays are quite affordable and built to take abuse, so they’re a good “first ashtray” while you figure out your needs.
If you have a dedicated smoking spot at home (indoors or on a patio) or you regularly relax with cigars in one place, a nice tabletop ashtray will likely become your best friend. Think about where you’ll spend most of your cigar time: Is it in a home lounge, a study, your garage or deck? In those cases, a larger ashtray that lives in that space makes sense. You won’t have to empty it as often, and it will comfortably hold your cigar during pauses. For the social smoker who often shares cigars with buddies, a multi-rest ashtray is practically a must so everyone isn’t juggling their cigar. Also, if presentation and atmosphere matter to you, the tabletop piece can enhance the ritual. Many cigar lovers derive almost as much pleasure from their accessories as from the cigars themselves – there’s a satisfaction in tapping your ash into a beautiful ashtray that might feature, say, the logo of a favorite cigar brand or a design that reflects your personality. As a beginner, you might not care about that yet, but over time you’ll likely appreciate having at least one quality ashtray at home.
There’s always the option to have both. In fact, most seasoned cigar enthusiasts do. There’s no rule that you must choose either portable or tabletop exclusively. You can use a heavyweight ashtray in your lounge and also keep a cheap portable in your car or travel humidor for when you’re out and about. Each serves its purpose. If you’re serious about getting into cigars, ultimately you’ll find owning both types covers all the bases: the tabletop ashtray for regular use at your favorite smoking spot, and the portable for flexibility on the go. Over time you may even acquire a few of each – perhaps a nicer crystal or ceramic piece for special occasions at home, and a couple of portable ones (one in the car, one in your golf bag, etc.). Cigar smoking is a personal journey, and as your experience grows, so might your collection of accessories.
To help you decide initially, here’s a quick comparison of the two types:
Size & Capacity: Tabletop ashtrays are larger and hold more ash (and often multiple cigars) than portables. If you smoke big cigars or multiple sticks in one sitting, a tabletop won’t fill up as quickly. Portable ashtrays are small – fine for one cigar’s worth of ash, but you’ll need to empty or tap out more often if you’re smoking back-to-back cigars.
Mobility: Obviously, portable ashtrays win here. You can slip them into a bag and use them anywhere. Tabletop ashtrays are meant to stay put. If you primarily smoke in one location, mobility may not matter; but if you like to roam with your cigar, go portable (or plan to carry your heavy ashtray around, which isn’t fun!).
Stability: Tabletop ashtrays, being heavier, are hard to tip over. They’re designed for stability – some even have non-slip bases. Portables are lighter and can be knocked over if you’re not careful (an errant elbow or gust of wind can send a flimsy ashtray flying). Some portables offset this by fitting into something (like the cup holder style) or using caps to contain ash, but in general they’re not as stable as a solid tabletop piece.
Cleanup and Maintenance: Both types need to be emptied and cleaned, but a tabletop might go longer between cleanings simply due to capacity. If you’re smoking outside, a deep or covered ashtray (portable or not) will keep ash from blowing around – something to consider especially for outdoor patios. Also, think about durability: metal or ceramic ashtrays clean up easily with a quick rinse or wipe. If ease of cleaning is a priority, avoid designs with too many nooks and crannies. Many cigar smokers like to dump the ash and give the tray a quick wash after each use to avoid stale smells, which works fine for both types. Just remember not to leave that nice tabletop ashtray out in the rain, as mentioned, and it will serve you for years.
Style and Impression: Do you want your ashtray to make a statement, or is it purely functional? A sleek porcelain or glass ashtray on your table sends a different vibe than a pocket metal ashtray. Neither is “better” – it’s personal preference. Tabletop ashtrays offer a chance to show a bit of luxury or personality (there’s a reason some are given as gifts or used to commemorate special cigar releases). Portable ashtrays are generally more modest, but there are some cool designs out there too. For example, cigar brands often create branded ashtrays and accessory sets that pair with their cigars – Davidoff’s elegant trays, LFD’s Andalusian Bull ashtray, or Drew Estate’s themed ashtray in the 20 Acre Farm collection are all ways to combine function with fandom. If you are the type who enjoys matching accessories or showcasing your cigar brand loyalty, a nice tabletop is a great addition. If you care less about looks and more about just having something handy to catch ash, a basic portable will do the trick.
In the end, choosing the right ashtray comes down to your needs and smoking environment. For new cigar smokers, our advice is: start with what fits your current situation, and you can always expand later. If you usually smoke one cigar on your porch in the evenings, a sturdy tabletop ashtray (maybe a simple heavy glass or ceramic one) will serve you well and feel more satisfying than using an old dish. If you find yourself without a consistent place to smoke and often have to create a temporary smoking spot, grab a portable ashtray – you’ll appreciate the flexibility. Many beginners actually get one of each type: for instance, a no-frills glass ashtray at home (easy to clean, hefty enough for outside use), and a travel ashtray to keep in the car or take on trips. This way, you’re covered in both scenarios without a big investment.
Finally, remember that a cigar ashtray is more than just a tray for ashes; it’s part of the ritual of enjoying a cigar. Whether it’s the simple pleasure of tapping ash into a well-made ashtray or the aesthetic of seeing your cigar resting in a beautiful dish, the right ashtray can enhance the overall experience. Take the time to pick one that suits your style and habits. As you grow in the hobby, you might even upgrade to a fancier piece or collect a few different ashtrays for different occasions. But at the core, there’s no wrong choice – portable and tabletop ashtrays each have their place, and both can greatly improve your cigar smoking life compared to using makeshift solutions. So, think about where you’ll be smoking, maybe try out one of each, and enjoy the peace of mind that comes with always having “somewhere to ash” that’s right for you.
Learn and Enjoy: A quality ashtray is a small step that can make a big difference for cigar lovers. By understanding the differences between portable and tabletop ashtrays, you’re better equipped to choose one (or both) that will keep your cigar sessions tidy, enjoyable, and classy. Happy smoking – and don’t forget to empty that ashtray when you’re done! Cheers.
Industry Resources
Knowing how to use a cigar cutter properly is one of the first skills every cigar smoker should master. A clean, precise cut ensures an even burn, a smooth draw, and keeps the wrapper from unraveling. Without the right cut, even the best cigar can feel disappointing. This guide will
Every cigar lover knows that the ritual of lighting up is a special moment – and using a luxury cigar lighter makes it even better. Whether you’re a seasoned smoker indulging in fine cigars daily, a collector of exquisite accessories, or searching for the perfect high-end gift for a cigar
Drop your email and phone number below to get your discount code.
StogieHub is the premier marketplace for high-quality cigar accessories, connecting cigar enthusiasts worldwide. Buy, sell, and discover exclusive cutters, lighters, humidors, and more in a secure, user-friendly platform built for the cigar community.
Drop your email and phone number below to get your discount code.